Plot Twist!
The plot twist editorial query
From time to time, world events occur that make fiction editors look at each other and say, “We can never again tell our authors their plot events are implausible!”
And I smile along with everyone else. But of course it’s not true. “It really happened” has never been a measure of whether a particular event is plausible in a novel.
Even if an author is basing a novel on true-life events, readers still expect to see that plot events follow the laws of cause-and-effect, that significant plot twists are foreshadowed and don’t just drop out of nowhere, and that characters have goals that drive plot events.
It doesn’t matter if at the eleventh hour the author bought a winning lottery ticket and saved their house from foreclosure. Readers aren’t going to buy that happening in a novel – and they’re not going to consider it a satisfactory resolution to a novel.
A plot event has to seem true, as if it could happen, given the story world, the characters, and the theme.
There is life and then there is story. They are two different things. We want story to reflect or illuminate life in some way but story does not and should not imitate life, or we would all wander off by page thirty to find something good to read.
So, rest assured: no matter what happens in the world, you haven’t written your last editorial query suggesting the author rethink the plausibilty of a plot event!
Other Helpful Content
-
Protecting Your Personal Values
The other day I was reading about a controversy inspired by the CEO of Salesforce. It was the usual “I once supported the values of the former president but now I support the values of the current president” kind of nonsense that owners and executives of large companies often (always?) spout in order to make…
-
Nontoxic Editing
The other day, I encountered a Washington Post headline that read, “These editor’s notes are poison. I learned from every drop.” I didn’t click the link because I don’t want to read about how writers should learn to appreciate abuse. And I’m not onboard with idolizing abusers. Every now and then you hear these stories…
