Copyediting vs Line Editing – What’s the difference?
Copyediting vs line editing: Let’s talk about the basic difference.
Copyediting and line editing both focus on the sentence level, but they are not the same thing. Copyediting is about ensuring consistency across a manuscript, correcting egregious errors, making sure the manuscript conforms to a specific style guide, and otherwise smoothing the prose so the reader doesn’t encounter any sentence-level hiccups as they read.
Example 1 – Difference between copyediting vs line editing
Here’s an example:
James and his father walked towards the barn it was a warm day with the sunshine brightly. The bull was in the pasture and he alerted because he seemed to be spearing something with his horns.
A CE might edit that to read:
James and his father walked towards the barn. It was a warm day with the sun shining brightly. The bull was in the pasture and James alerted because the bull seemed to be spearing something with his horns.
The CE isn’t worried about whether the scene is very entertaining or if the character development is effective. The CE is just making sure the sentences are understandable.
An LE is less concerned about making sure the commas are in the right place and more concerned with ensuring that the prose is as effective (and in the case of fiction, emotionally compelling) as it can be.
Example 2 – Do you see the difference?
Here’s an example:
A few minutes later, they reached a small collection of fisherfolk cottages that lay outside the eastern stretch of the city wall, and they slowed to a walk, Lucinda breathing fast and Meretropia pausing to take deep lungsful of air.
“The Denu are coming!” Lucinda called out to the first householder she met, an older woman with her arms full of firewood. “Seek shelter! The Denu are coming!”
The woman frowned at her, then shook her head as if to judge the folly of some people and went inside her cottage.
Simon joined her cry: “The Denu are coming!”
Reading that, you may feel that something isn’t working quite as well as it could. An LE would recognize that the tension is being drained by having the characters slow down. Also, the LE would see that the verb “reached” isn’t very active. The LE might make the following edit:
They raced towards a small collection of fisherfolk cottages that lay outside the eastern stretch of the city wall.
“The Denu are coming!” Lucinda called out to the first householder she met, an older woman with her arms full of firewood. “Seek shelter! The Denu are coming!”
The woman frowned at her, then shook her head as if to judge the folly of some people and went inside her cottage.
Simon joined her cry: “The Denu are coming!”
Simple distinction between these types of editing
As you can see, an LE diagnoses what is causing story problems at the sentence level. A CE is more concerned about what is causing readability problems at the sentence level.
The barebones difference between copyediting vs line editing: Both are diagnosed at the sentence level, but line editing looks at what is causing story problems and copyediting focuses on what is causing readability problems.
Other Helpful Content
Your Year-End Review
This time of year, things slow down at Club Ed and I have time to reflect on the past year. I always learn a new lesson or two. This year, the lesson was “simplify.” It may not look like it when you see all of the classes available on Club Ed, but we’ve streamlined a…
Simplifying Your Editorial Business
In June, a plugin conflict caused the Club Ed website to crash. This was after a server problem took it offline for a weekend and we had to switch hosts. I thought I was going to lose my mind. Having Club Ed offline not only costs money but greatly inconveniences students. The website developer said,…
Doubting Your Work vs Doubting Yourself
Newer editors often struggle with imposter syndrome, which is the feeling that they’re not really good at their work and pretty soon everyone will see right through them and point their fingers and laugh. I’ve struggled with this (imposter syndrome, not pointing fingers and laughing) off-and-on throughout my career, as do most people who want…
