Editorial Terms and Their Meanings
Here’s a rundown of basic editorial terms and their meanings to help you understand editing terminology.
When I talk about the author’s work of addressing areas of concern, I call it revision to distinguish it from what an editor does, which is editing. Most people writing and speaking on the subject don’t distinguish between the two but since I write a lot about the interaction between the editorial process and the authorial process, I find it creates less confusion to use the terms in this way.
If you’re a writer who calls the work you do on a drafted manuscript editing, that’s fine! I’m not saying you should change. I’m just explaining why I use the terminology I do.
I also use the term revision letter to describe the several-page document that outlines the overall revision I suggest the author make. This is also sometimes called an edit letter or editorial letter but since it guides the author’s revision, for the sake of clarity and consistency with my other terminology, I call it a revision letter.
Editorial queries are the comments an editor leaves on a manuscript to show the author where a specific revision is needed. For example, “AU: Here in Chapter 3, Greta’s motivation for quitting her job isn’t clear. It makes her later desperation to take any job she can get less plausible. Consider strengthening her motivation by showing her have an argument with her boss because he wants her to do something unethical, or maybe he bullies and insults her. Then her storming out of his office and saying ‘I quit!’ will be more understandable.”
An author is certainly able to find some other solution to the motivation problem, or to decide that they don’t agree that there’s a problem at all. But this information provides enough guidance for an author to understand what I think an issue is and how I think it could be addressed.
Some editors call these queries manuscript comments or feedback on the manuscript itself but editorial query is the term used in publishing. Since I have publisher clients, I also use this language.
An editorial query is of course different from a query letter, which is a description of a project that authors send to literary agents in order to interest them in representing the project. Since both are sometimes called queries it can be confusing but if you look at the context, it will usually become clear which is being referred to.
An editorial round is one complete edit. In development, this consists of ms queries and a revision letter. A ms may require more than one round of development. In traditional publishing, all manuscripts go through several rounds of editing, typically including a development round, a copyediting round, and a galley proofing round (galleys are the final uncorrected version of the ms just before the ms is finalized and published).
An editorial pass is the editor going through the ms one time, addressing errors. Most editors take several passes through a ms to complete one editorial round
A revision round is the author revising the ms completely in response to an editorial round. Like an editor, authors may take several passes through the ms in order to complete the round. When the author feels they’ve addressed the concerns to the best of their ability, the revision round is complete.
Tips for Editors & Writers
Your Year-End Review
This time of year, things slow down at Club Ed and I have time to reflect on the past year. I always learn a new lesson or two. This year, the lesson was “simplify.” It may not look like it when you see all of the classes available on Club Ed, but we’ve streamlined a…
Simplifying Your Editorial Business
In June, a plugin conflict caused the Club Ed website to crash. This was after a server problem took it offline for a weekend and we had to switch hosts. I thought I was going to lose my mind. Having Club Ed offline not only costs money but greatly inconveniences students. The website developer said,…
Doubting Your Work vs Doubting Yourself
Newer editors often struggle with imposter syndrome, which is the feeling that they’re not really good at their work and pretty soon everyone will see right through them and point their fingers and laugh. I’ve struggled with this (imposter syndrome, not pointing fingers and laughing) off-and-on throughout my career, as do most people who want…
